#1 Car Accident Lawyer in St. Augustine, FL + 2025 Accident Hotspots
- April Karaffa
- Nov 3
- 5 min read
Were you recently in a car accident in St. Augustine? Your insurance company may not be paying the full amount you deserve. Protect Your Rights. The time immediately following a car accident is crucial for preserving evidence and building a strong case. Contact our experienced St. Augustine car accident lawyers today for a free, no-obligation consultation. Let us put our fierce advocacy and compassionate guidance to work for you. Call us or fill out the contact form to get started.
St. Augustine is a relatively safe place to drive, but there are definitely some car accident hot spots you should be aware of.
Here are the Top 10 streets with car accidents in St. Augustine in 2025:
State Road 16 (SR 16)
US Highway 1 South
US Highway 1
State Road 207 (SR 207)
State Road 312 (SR 312)
International Golf Parkway
King Street
US Highway 1 North
Country Road 210 (CR210)
State Road 206 (SR 206)
Driving in St. Augustine tests even the most seasoned drivers. A fusion of tourist traffic, explosive growth, and a colonial-era grid creates several notorious choke points. The three most consistently challenging spots are the historic downtown, the May Street and San Marco Avenue intersection, and the I-95 corridor through St. Johns County.
Historic Downtown
Downtown’s historic core funnels modern vehicles through narrow streets never meant for cars. This fundamental mismatch guarantees headaches for anyone behind the wheel.
Gridlock: The area is frequently paralyzed by standstill traffic, especially on weekends and during tourist season.
Parking Scarcity: The hunt for limited parking adds to the congestion as drivers circle endlessly.
Mixed Traffic: You aren't just dodging cars; you're navigating a constant flow of pedestrians, tour trolleys, and horse-drawn carriages. King Street, the Bayfront, and the approach to the Bridge of Lions are consistent bottlenecks.
May Street & San Marco Avenue Intersection
This junction near the Vilano Bridge is a well-known source of frustration. Traffic converging from Vilano Beach and downtown creates frequent, lengthy delays. Its complex layout, with multiple lanes and turning options, often confuses unfamiliar drivers. Though recent modifications like a new traffic loop aim to improve flow, they still present a learning curve.
Interstate 95
The stretch of I-95 through St. Johns County is notoriously dangerous. A volatile mix of high-speed local commuters and long-distance travelers on an already congested highway significantly elevates accident risk.
High Crash Rate: The section from the Duval County line to State Road 16 has a grim history of serious and fatal accidents.
Aggressive Driving: Speeding and reckless maneuvers are rampant.
Sudden Hazards: Frequent congestion and unpredictable construction zones create conditions for dangerous, sudden stops.
Here’s the three year car accident trend in St Augustine. Accidents have increased a modest 5% compared to the overall 7 county trend that decreases by 4% when comparing 2021 averages to 2024 and 2025’s results.
For all car accidents in St. Augustine, the following is the light condition when the accident occurred. 78% of accidents occur during daylight, which aligns to rush hours that occur in daylight hours.
Weather Condition: 79% of all accidents in St Augustine are during clear weather, and only 7% are during rainy periods.
Road Surface: 88% of car accidents are when the road is dry.
When should you consult St. Augustine’s #1 Car Accident Lawyer?
Regardless of road condition, weather, light condition or any other contributory factors, if you were injured, don't let them dictate the terms of your recovery. Your fight for justice starts now. Call the Moore Law Firm now to speak to our lawyers, or start with the contact form.
The following is data around the types of car accident impacts in St Augustine over the past 3 years:
34% is a rear-ender type of collision
21% is “Other”
17% is at an angle
13% is a sideswipe
The balance trails off fairly quickly…
Here are the types of objects that people hit in St Augustine:
The percentage of accidents in St Augustine that are day vs night:
Comparing car accidents in St Augustine to the rest of NE Florida on several key metrics, we find the following outliers:
Injuries: St. Augustine has a notably lower percentage of accidents that result in injuries compared to the overall total (a 15% difference). This is the most significant outlier.
Distracted Driving: Conversely, St. Augustine has a much higher percentage of accidents caused by distracted drivers (24%) compared to the overall average of 13%.
Aging Drivers: Accidents involving aging drivers are also more frequent in St. Augustine (29%) than the overall percentage of 21%.
Hit & Run: St. Augustine experiences a lower percentage of hit-and-run accidents (12%) compared to the overall total (17%).
Intersection Accidents: Accidents at intersections are slightly more common in St. Augustine (31%) than the overall average of 27%.
FAQ
How much money does The Moore Law Firm charge to take on your car accident case in St Augustine?
You pay nothing unless your lawyer wins money for you
Should I hire an attorney after a car accident in St Augustine FL?
Yes, you should consider hiring an attorney after a car accident in St. Augustine, Florida, especially if you've suffered injuries or significant property damage. An experienced local attorney will handle the complex negotiations with insurance companies and navigate Florida's specific "no-fault" insurance laws to ensure you receive fair compensation. Since most personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis and offer free consultations, there's no financial risk in exploring your legal options.
How soon must I file a car accident case in St. Augustine?
For a car accident in St. Augustine, Florida, you generally have two years from the date of the accident to file a lawsuit for personal injuries. This new, shorter deadline applies to accidents that occurred on or after March 24, 2023, due to a recent change in state law. If your accident was before that date, the previous four-year statute of limitations still applies.
How can I prove negligence in a St Augustine car accident case?
To prove negligence in a St. Augustine car accident, you must demonstrate that the other driver breached their legal duty to operate their vehicle safely, and that this breach directly caused your injuries and damages. You can accomplish this by gathering crucial evidence such as the official police report, photos and videos of the accident scene, and statements from eyewitnesses. This evidence, combined with your medical records and repair bills, helps establish a clear link between the other party's careless actions and the financial and physical harm you suffered.
Data Source: FDOT Crash Database 2022 - June 2025
